Debate Grows Over Quantum-Resistant BIP-360 Upgrade

Markets 2025-12-18 22:06

Debate Grows Over Quantum-Resistant BIP-360 Upgrade

A small but growing group of Bitcoin advocates and fund managers is pushing for faster work on quantum-resistant signatures, arguing that even the perception of a future quantum threat could become a market risk before it is practical.

Supporters have pointed to a draft Bitcoin Improvement Proposal, BIP-360, which would add a post-quantum signature option for addresses viewed as potentially vulnerable to future advances in quantum computing.

Calls for a 2026 timeline

Charles Edwards, founder of Capriole, said the implementation must be finalized and deployed in 2026, while noting it would require coordination across hardware wallet providers, node operators, and exchanges.

Edwards wrote:

“Around 20-30% of Bitcoin will be taken by a quantum hacker in the next few years.”

He added:

“I believe we should burn all coins that do not migrate to BIP-360 by 2028.”

Back and Mow push back on urgency

Others dismissed the idea that quantum computing poses a near-term threat to Bitcoin.

Blockstream CEO Adam Back argued the risk is still far off, writing that the threat is “decades away,” and criticized quantum fear, uncertainty, and doubt.

Jan3 CEO Samson Mow also mocked the idea that current quantum machines could break Bitcoin, writing:

“Quantum computing can’t even factor 21, yet people are panic selling because they think it will kill Bitcoin.”

Taproot usage raises questions

Bitcoin analyst Willy Woo said Taproot usage has fallen from 42% of transactions in 2024 to 20%, calling the decline unusual.

Woo wrote:

“I’ve NEVER seen the latest format losing adoption before. Taproot is Quantum Vulnerable, while older SegWit and Legacy are not.”

Competing post-quantum ideas

Back has also proposed a hash-based signature approach as a post-quantum alternative, according to a Blockstream Research paper released Dec. 5.

Bitcoin currently relies on ECDSA and Schnorr signatures to authorize spending, and any new standard would require broad ecosystem consensus.

Share to:

This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.

Curated Series

SuperEx Popular Science Articles Column

SuperEx Popular Science Articles Column

This collection features informative articles about SuperEx, aiming to simplify complex cryptocurrency concepts for a wider audience. It covers the basics of trading, blockchain technology, and the features of the SuperEx platform. Through easy-to-understand content, it helps users navigate the world of digital assets with confidence and clarity.

Unstaked related news and market dynamics research

Unstaked related news and market dynamics research

Unstaked (UNSD) is a blockchain platform integrating AI agents for automated community engagement and social media interactions. Its native token supports governance, staking, and ecosystem features. This special feature explores Unstaked’s market updates, token dynamics, and platform development.

XRP News and Research

XRP News and Research

This series focuses on XRP, covering the latest news, market dynamics, and in-depth research. Featured analysis includes price trends, regulatory developments, and ecosystem growth, providing a clear overview of XRP's position and potential in the cryptocurrency market.

How do beginners trade options?How does option trading work?

How do beginners trade options?How does option trading work?

This special feature introduces the fundamentals of options trading for beginners, explaining how options work, their main types, and the mechanics behind trading them. It also explores key strategies, potential risks, and practical tips, helping readers build a clear foundation to approach the options market with confidence.

What are the risks of investing in cryptocurrency?

What are the risks of investing in cryptocurrency?

This special feature covers the risks of investing in cryptocurrency, explaining common challenges such as market volatility, security vulnerabilities, regulatory uncertainties, and potential scams. It also provides analysis of risk management strategies and mitigation techniques, helping readers gain a clear understanding of how to navigate the crypto market safely.