Circle (NYSE: CRCL) is at the center of a heated debate within the Chinese community regarding its investment potential, following a robust Q3 2025 earnings report. The company reported a 66% increase in revenue year-over-year, reaching $740 million, and a net profit of $214 million. Despite these strong figures, Circle's stock fell 11.4% on the day of the earnings release and continued to decline by 20% over the following week. Critics question the sustainability of Circle's business model, pointing to high distribution and operational costs, and a significant portion of profits derived from non-recurring investment gains. The debate also touches on whether Circle should be viewed as a bank or a financial infrastructure provider, with comparisons drawn to companies like Amazon and JD.com, which initially operated at a loss to capture market share. Concerns about interest rate risks and competition from traditional financial institutions further fuel the discussion on Circle's long-term valuation and potential.